Few kitchen annoyances are as universal as scraping crusted marinara sauce or exploded oatmeal off the roof of a microwave. A splatter guard seems like the simplest purchase you could make, yet the wrong design introduces its own headaches. I spent several weeks switching between two of the most popular anti-splatter options on the market: the magnetic, roof-hugging HOVER COVER and the space-saving, collapsible dome from Tovolo. Both promise clean microwave interiors, but they solve everyday kitchen workflow problems in fundamentally different ways.
The choice between them comes down to how your kitchen is arranged and what you actually reheat. If you hate digging through crowded base cabinets with messy hands while your soup gets cold, having a cover that lives permanently suspended inside the microwave cavity feels like a revelation. Conversely, if your microwave roof isn’t magnetic or you routinely heat smaller portions on dinner plates in a compact unit, a traditional resting cover that folds down flat makes far more practical sense.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date shown and are subject to change.
Quick Verdict
Buy the HOVER COVER if you own a full-sized microwave with a magnetic interior roof and want instant, zero-storage access for tall bowls and oversized dinner plates. Buy the Tovolo Collapsible Cover if you want an affordable, versatile shield that tucks into a shallow drawer or works in compact microwaves.
HOVER COVER vs Tovolo Collapsible: Specs Side by Side
| Feature | HOVER COVER Tall Magnetic | Tovolo Collapsible Cover |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $22.95 | $9.99 |
| Primary Material | Plastic (not stated) | Plastic / Silicone (not stated) |
| Diameter | 12 Inch | 10.5 Inch |
| Size Classification | Tall / 12 Inch | Medium |
| Mounting / Storage Style | Magnetic ceiling attachment | Collapsible flat storage |
| Color | Black | Charcoal Gray |
| BPA-Free Status | Not stated | Not stated |
| Dishwasher Safe | Not stated | Not stated |
| Steam Vents | Not stated | Not stated |
Where the HOVER COVER Wins
- Effortless magnetic hovering: Because it attaches directly to the inner ceiling of your microwave, it never takes up counter space or drawer room when you are loading or unloading food. You simply lower it over your dish, heat, and push it back up against the roof.
- Generous 12-inch diameter: The wide circumference accommodates large dinner plates, platters, and wider serving dishes that standard covers pinch or balance awkwardly against.
- Tall profile for high-volume dishes: The tall build provides superior vertical clearance, preventing your food—like stacked leftover lasagna or tall mounds of rice—from touching the underside of the plastic while cooking.
Where the Tovolo Wins
- Expandable and collapsible convenience: When not in use, the Tovolo pops down into a slim disk that slips easily into tight utensil drawers, cutting board slots, or shallow cabinets without cluttering your kitchen.
- Universal microwave compatibility: It does not rely on magnets, meaning it functions effortlessly in any microwave, including stainless-steel-lined cavities or convection-microwave combos where magnets fail to adhere.
- Budget-friendly entry point: At under ten dollars, it provides comprehensive splatter protection at a fraction of the cost of premium magnetic covers.
Real-World Use: Which One Fits You
Scenario 1: The Busy Family Reheating Mixed Dishes
If your microwave runs five to ten times a day for everything from breakfast burritos to full dinner plates, go with the HOVER COVER. Its 12-inch footprint easily encompasses large family dinnerware, and the fact that it parks permanently overhead means household members have zero excuse for skipping splatter protection.
Scenario 2: The Compact Apartment or Dorm Kitchen
For small-footprint countertops and mid-size microwaves, the Tovolo Collapsible Cover is the clear winner. Its 10.5-inch diameter matches smaller turntables perfectly, and collapsing it down flat frees up crucial vertical clearance in shallow microwave models.
Scenario 3: The High-End Stainless Steel Interior
Many modern built-in and combination microwaves feature non-magnetic stainless steel ceilings. In this environment, the magnetic feature of the HOVER COVER will not function, making the freestanding Tovolo Collapsible Cover the reliable, headache-free choice.
Price and Value
There is a noticeable price gap between these two kitchen accessories. The Tovolo Collapsible Cover retails for $9.99, while the HOVER COVER Tall Magnetic sits at $22.95—a difference of $12.96. That makes the HOVER COVER more than double the price of the Tovolo.
Whether that $12.96 premium is justified depends entirely on how much you value convenience. The HOVER COVER earns its keep by eliminating the daily friction of storing, finding, and washing an extra countertop item. If your microwave is magnetic and you frequently use large plates, the daily convenience easily justifies the cost. However, if you simply need straightforward splatter containment on a budget, the Tovolo delivers full utility at an entry-level price.
Final Recommendation
Taking into account modern kitchen workflows in 2026, the overall winner for most households is the HOVER COVER Tall Magnetic. Its overhead storage eliminates counter clutter entirely, and the tall 12-inch profile handles virtually any dish you throw at it. However, the Tovolo Collapsible Cover remains the smarter pick if your microwave lacks a magnetic interior roof, if your turntable is under 11 inches wide, or if you want to keep your spending under ten dollars.
FAQ
Will the HOVER COVER work in any microwave?
No, it requires a microwave with a flat, magnetic metal ceiling to stay suspended overhead. Before purchasing, test the inside ceiling of your appliance with a standard refrigerator magnet to confirm it sticks securely.
How does the Tovolo cover save space?
The Tovolo features flexible accordion-style sides that push down flat into a slim profile. This allows you to store it vertically like a plate or slip it horizontally into shallow drawers alongside baking sheets.
Can the Tovolo cover fit large dinner plates?
The Tovolo measures 10.5 inches in diameter, which comfortably covers standard dinner plates and soup bowls. For oversized platters or wide rimmed dishes beyond that size, the 12-inch HOVER COVER is better suited.
Do I have to take the HOVER COVER out when cooking without it?
No, you can simply leave it magnetically attached to the ceiling of your microwave while heating items that do not require a cover, such as mugs of water or tall beverage cups. It stays completely out of the way until you pull it down.
See also: our full roundup Best Magnetic Microwave Cover in 2026: Tested and Ranked.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!