⏱ 9 min read  ·  ✅ Updated Nov 2026
⭐ Key Takeaways
Quick answer: Our top pick is Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack, with Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack as a strong alternative.

A donut pan is an oven pan with ring-shaped cavities that turns cake batter into baked donuts, no deep fryer needed. Pipe or spoon batter into the rings, bake until set, then glaze or dust while warm. Baked donuts come out lighter than fried ones, and cleanup is far easier than dealing with a pot of hot oil.

This guide covers oven donut pans only, which is an important distinction. An electric donut maker is a countertop appliance that bakes donuts between heated plates, and it is a different product with its own trade-offs around storage, capacity, and cleaning. Baked cake donuts are also different from fried yeast donuts, which need proofing time and hot oil. If you want a pan that goes in the oven you already own, the five picks below cover the main formats: rigid nonstick steel sets, a deep-cavity steel set, flexible silicone molds, and a shaped aluminum pan for cruller-style donuts.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Quick Answer

For most home bakers, a two-pack of six-cavity nonstick steel pans is the best donut pan setup, because it bakes a full dozen at once and releases cleanly. Silicone molds suit bakers who want flexible release and easy storage, while a shaped aluminum pan suits bakers who want cruller-style donuts. Check cavity size and oven fit before buying, since pans that look similar can make very different donuts.

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

The Bellemain Premiere set is the most straightforward pick in this guide: two rigid steel pans, six molds each, with a nonstick coating that helps cake donuts release without tearing. Baking a dozen at once matters more than it sounds, because donut batter waits poorly once mixed, and a second pan lets you get the whole batch in the oven while the batter is still light. The pans measure 12.5 by 8.5 inches, which fits a standard home oven and a standard cooling rack.

Steel gives this set an edge over thin pans that flex and warp. A rigid pan holds its shape in a hot oven, so the rings stay round and the donuts bake evenly. The trade-off is care: hand washing is the safer routine for nonstick steel, since metal utensils can damage the coating. This set also works for bagels, which use the same ring shape and a firmer dough, so one pan covers weekend donuts and occasional bagel batches.

Spec Detail
Material Steel with nonstick coating
Cavities 6 per pan
Pan size 12.5 x 8.5 in
Pack 2 pans
Care Hand wash recommended
UPC 810046311219
Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Check price on Amazon

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Check price on Amazon

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Check price on Amazon

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Check price on Amazon

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Bellemain Premiere Donut Pan, 2-Pack

Check price on Amazon

NutriChef Nonstick Donut Pans, 2-Pack

The NutriChef set is the other rigid steel two-pack in this guide, and it stands out for its heat rating and its dishwasher-safe care. The carbon steel pans carry a nonstick silicone coating and are oven safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which covers the full range of baked donut recipes. Each pan measures about 12.59 by 8.26 inches, so it fits the same ovens as the Bellemain set.

The main difference between the two steel sets is small but worth noting. NutriChef lists its pans as dishwasher safe, which suits a baker who wants the fastest cleanup after a batch. In practice, hand washing still extends the life of any nonstick surface, even one rated for the dishwasher, so treat the dishwasher rating as a convenience rather than a daily habit. Like the Bellemain set, this one bakes twelve full-size donuts per round across two pans.

Spec Detail
Material Carbon steel with nonstick silicone coating
Cavities 6 per pan
Pan size 12.59 x 8.26 in
Pack 2 pans
Max oven temp 450 F
Care Dishwasher safe
Model NCDP2LGBK
UPC 842893171135

HONGBAKE Donut Pan, 2-Pack, Black

The HONGBAKE set takes a different approach: its cavities are deeper than a standard donut pan, so the batter has more room to rise. The result is a taller, fuller donut with a soft interior, closer in feel to a small bundt cake than to a flat ring. The pans are heavy-duty carbon steel with a nonstick coating, sold as a two-pack with six cavities per pan, and they are oven safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.

Deep cavities are a real advantage if your donuts keep coming out thin or flat, but they change the shape enough that you should check expectations before buying. The donuts from this pan read as mini bundt cakes as much as classic rings. For a baker who likes a thick, cakey donut, that is a feature. For a baker chasing a classic bakery ring, a standard-depth pan is the safer choice. Use a piping bag to fill the deep cavities evenly, since spooning batter into a deep ring tends to leave air pockets, and let the donuts cool in the pan for a few minutes before turning them out.

Spec Detail
Material Carbon steel with nonstick coating
Cavities 6 per pan
Pack 2 pans
Max oven temp 450 F
First available July 23, 2021
UPC 767155575196

Walfos Silicone Donut Mold, Set of 2

The Walfos set is the flexible option in this guide: two silicone molds with six cavities each, made from BPA-free silicone. Silicone releases differently from metal. Instead of lifting a donut out of a rigid ring, you push it out from below, which is gentler on glazed or delicate cakes. The molds are dishwasher safe, and they stack flat for storage, which suits a small kitchen.

Flexibility has a cost, and it is support. A silicone mold sags when full of batter, so set each mold on a baking sheet before filling it, and carry the sheet rather than the mold. Silicone also browns less than metal, so donuts from this set come out paler on the outside even when the center is fully baked. Use a toothpick to check the center rather than judging by color, and let the donuts cool in the mold before pushing them out, since a hot donut can tear.

Spec Detail
Material BPA-free silicone
Cavities 6 per mold
Pack 2 molds
Care Dishwasher safe
Max oven temp not stated
First available August 10, 2020

Nordic Ware French Twist Donut Pan

The Nordic Ware French Twist is the shaped pick in this guide, and it makes the most distinctive donuts of the five. Its six cavities are twisted, so the finished donuts look like French crullers, with ridged edges that catch glaze. The pan is formed aluminum, which spreads heat evenly across the cavities, and it measures 14.9 by 10.3 by 1.1 inches, with cavities about 3.9 inches across. It is part of Nordic Ware’s Northern Lights collection, finished in Twilight Blue.

A shaped pan is a different kind of purchase from a standard ring pan. The twist gives every donut a finished look with no extra decorating, which suits a baker who serves donuts to guests or gives them as gifts. The trade-off is versatility: this pan makes one shape, and it takes up more room, since the formed aluminum body is wider than the steel pans in this guide. Grease the ridges lightly, and confirm stock before ordering, since an older listing crawl showed no featured offers.

Spec Detail
Material Formed aluminum
Cavities 6, twisted
Pan size 14.9 x 10.3 x 1.1 in
Cavity diameter 3.9 in
Finish Twilight Blue
Model 30075
UPC 011172300751

How to Choose

Start with cavity size, because it decides what your donuts look like. Full-size cavities make donuts about 3 to 4 inches across, which is the classic bakery ring. Mini cavities make smaller donuts that bake faster and suit children or party platters, but they are a different product, so check the cavity count and the pan dimensions together rather than trusting the word mini or full-size alone.

Next, choose between rigid metal and flexible silicone. Rigid steel and aluminum pans brown better and hold their shape. Silicone molds release more gently and store flat, but they need a baking sheet underneath and they brown less. If you bake weekly, a rigid steel two-pack is the more durable setup.

Then check the pack size. A two-pack bakes a dozen at once, which matches most cake donut recipes and avoids a second round with tired batter. A single pan costs less and stores more easily, but it halves your batch. Finally, check oven fit and care. Measure the inside of your oven before ordering, since the largest pan in this guide is nearly 15 inches wide. Hand washing extends the life of any nonstick coating, even on pans rated dishwasher safe.

Who Should Skip It

Skip a donut pan if you mainly want fried yeast donuts. A pan bakes cake donuts, which are denser and quicker, while yeast donuts need proofing and hot oil. No pan in this guide fries, and a baked donut will not taste like one from a fryer, no matter how good the glaze is.

Skip it too if you bake donuts only once or twice a year. A muffin pan can bake donut batter in a pinch, and a single-purpose pan earns its shelf space only when it gets used. The same applies if your oven is small: measure first, since the wider pans in this guide may not fit a compact oven. Finally, skip the shaped and deep-cavity pans if you want a classic ring every time. The French Twist makes cruller-style donuts and the HONGBAKE makes taller, bundt-like donuts, and neither makes the standard bakery ring.

FAQ

Are baked donuts as good as fried donuts?

They are different rather than better or worse. Baked donuts are lighter, cakier, and quicker to make, with no hot oil to manage. Fried donuts are richer and chewier, with a crisp outside. If you want a fast weekend treat, baked donuts win. If you want a classic yeast donut, a pan will not get you there.

Do I need to grease a nonstick donut pan?

Yes, lightly. A thin coat of oil or baking spray helps the donuts release cleanly, especially in shaped or deep cavities where batter can catch. Too much grease pools in the rings and makes the donuts soggy, so use a light hand.

Can I use a donut pan for bagels?

Yes, with the right dough. Bagel dough is firmer than cake batter, so shape each piece into a ring and press it into the cavity rather than pouring. The pan helps bagels hold a round shape in the oven, but it does not replace boiling, which gives bagels their chewy crust.

Why did my donuts stick to the pan?

The most common causes are an ungreased pan, a damaged nonstick coating, or turning the donuts out too soon. Grease lightly, avoid metal utensils and abrasive pads, and let the donuts cool in the pan for a few minutes so the crumb sets before you release them.

Final Verdict

For most home bakers, a two-pack of six-cavity nonstick steel pans is the best donut pan setup, and the Bellemain set is the simplest version of it. The NutriChef set is the better pick if you want a higher heat rating and dishwasher-safe care. Choose the HONGBAKE set for taller, cakier donuts, the Walfos molds for flexible release and flat storage, and the Nordic Ware French Twist when you want cruller-style donuts that look finished with no extra work.